Stories from the Stringam Family Ranches of Southern Alberta

From the 50s and 60s to today . . .



Friday, November 20, 2026

Peter-ing Out

 

Peter, Peter, pumpkin eater,
Had a wife but couldn’t keep her;
He put her in a pumpkin shell
And there he kept her very well.


Peter, Peter, pumpkin eater,
Had another and didn’t love her;
Peter learned to read and spell,
And then he loved her very well.

 

This poem has always intrigued me.
I mean…Peter, pumpkin eater?
I probably don’t have to point out that no other foods are mentioned.
That could mean our dear Peter ate only pumpkin (a-member-of-the-squash-family-and-not-a-member-of-the-marrow-family-and-I-know-this-because-I-went-all-the-way-over-to-Wikipedia-and-looked-it-up!) or was, in fact, a pumpkin farmer.
So back to our boy and his proclivity for pumpkins.
Wouldn’t you agree that Peter, Peter Pumpkin Eater is a very good introduction?
We know, right off, that Peter must be all kinds of refined, especially to us fellow pumpkin aficionados.
Or Pumpkinados, as we prefer.
Right?
But though this poem got my attention right away, I have to admit it makes a bit of a left turn partway through.
Peter had a wife (let’s call her Polly) and couldn’t keep her.
What?
Was Polly’s marriage to him something more – or less – than she bargained for?
Didn’t she want to be up to her eyebrows in pumpkin?
Did the old girl keep wandering off and getting lost?
This begs an explanation.
Especially when considering the next part, where he ‘puts’ her in a pumpkin shell and keeps her very well.
Ummm…could we have a bit of clarification on that, please?
Scenario #1. Are we talking about a pumpkin so large one could set up housekeeping?
Peter: “Hon! I realize that I…erm…snore a bit. So, to make your life easier, I’ve grown a sweet little apartment for you out in the garden.
Because nothing says ‘Happy Marriage’ like husby comfortable in the house and wife ‘comfortable’ in a squash shell in the garden…
Wherein Polly says, “Oh, Peter! How considerate! Wait…grown?!”
Peter: “It may be a bit on the ‘moist and stringy’ side. But a coat of paint or two will put it right!”
Polly: “You’re always thinking of me! Wait…moist and stringy?!”
And one last thing to mention before we move on.
And I can say this in one word: Rot?
Now scenario #2. Even more disturbing…
Are we talking a normally-sized pumpkin shell wherein one would have to be chopped up into little bits to be placed…erp…therein. With a few veggies and potatoes in a nice, rich broth?
Pumpkin eating is sounding less and less appetizing.
Just sayin’.
But you have to admit that the next stanza rather supports scenario #2.
Because we learn in reading further that Peter remarries – let’s call wife 2.0 ‘Priscilla’.
So, what happened to Polly? Hmmmm? Anyone else suspicious here?
Polly’s disappearance would make this second marriage to Priscilla only a little more legal. Till Peter is locked up for Uxoricide. (See above – Bits, broth, etc.)
Ew.
Personally, either scenario would kind of put the binders on any of my pending attachments.
But I digress…
Then we learn that marriage to Priscilla (wife 2.0) seems to be lacking in love.
And when reading further, we are told that, perhaps what has been lacking all along was Peter’s illiterate-ness?
That reading and writing are all that’s needed to ensure love?
Huh. Imagine that.
An education could be beneficial!
Who knew?
So Peter, he of the pumpkin proclivity, banishes Polly to a moist and possibly rotting ‘shelter’ in the garden or bakes her in one of the aforementioned pumpkins.
Then livens up his second marriage to Priscilla with a little reading time?
Didn’t see that coming…
But just to be safe, if good ol’ Peter invites you over for story-time and some of his ‘world famous’ baked pumpkin?
Refuse.

It's Fly on the Wall time!
My favourite day of the month! 
When my sister bloggers and I get together to tell you what has been going on in our lives, hearts and homes this month.
And I get to massacre another Fairy Tale!
Life is good.
You've read my entry...now hurry over and see what my sister bloggers have been up to!
You'll be glad you did!

1 comment:

  1. I too wondered what in the heck was: "Couldn't keep her?" Maybe that meant she had too rich taste for him? Or she just flew the coop? Alas, we'll never know, but being put into a pumpkin shell is no fun either way.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for visiting! Now tell us your story!

Mechanical Murders

Mechanical Murders
A Phychological Murder Mystery!

Real Estates: All Murders Included in the Price!

Real Estates: All Murders Included in the Price!
My FIRST murder mystery!

Blessed by a Curse

Blessed by a Curse
My very first Medieval Romance!

God's Tree

God's Tree
For the Children

Third in the series

Third in the series
Deborah. Fugitive of Faith

The Long-Awaited Sequel to Daughter of Ishmael

The Long-Awaited Sequel to Daughter of Ishmael
A House Divided is now available at all fine bookstores and on Amazon.com and .ca!

Daughter of Ishmael

Daughter of Ishmael
Now available at Amazon.com and .ca and Chapters.ca and other fine bookstores.

Romance still wins!

Romance still wins!
First romance in a decade!

Hosts: Your Room's Ready

Hosts: Your Room's Ready
A fun romp through the world's most haunted hotel!

Hugs, Delivered.

Compass Book Ratings

Compass Book Ratings

Ghost of the Overlook

Ghost of the Overlook
Need a fright?

My Granddaughter is Carrying on the Legacy!

My Granddaughter is Carrying on the Legacy!
New Tween Novel!

Gnome for Christmas

Gnome for Christmas
The newest in my Christmas Series

SnowMan

SnowMan
A heart warming story of love and sacrifice.

Translate

My novel, Carving Angels

My novel, Carving Angels
Read it! You know you want to!

My Second Novel: Kris Kringle's Magic

My Second Novel: Kris Kringle's Magic
What could be better than a second Christmas story?!

Join me on Maven

Connect with me on Maven

Essence

Essence
A scientist and his son struggle to keep their earth-shattering discovery out of the wrong hands.

Essence: A Second Dose

Essence: A Second Dose
Captured and imprisoned, a scientist and his son use their amazing discovery to foil evil plans.

Looking for a Great Read?

E-Books by Diane Stringam Tolley
Available from Smashwords.com

The Babysitter

The Babysitter
A baby-kidnapping ring has its eye on J'Aime and her tiny niece.

Melissa

Melissa
Haunted by her past, Melissa must carve a future. Without Cain.

Devon

Devon
Following tragedy, Devon retreats to the solitude of the prairie. Until a girl is dropped in his lap.

Pearl, Why You Little...

Pearl, Why You Little...
Everyone should spend a little time with Pearl!

The Marketing Mentress

The Marketing Mentress
Building solid relationships with podcast and LinkedIn marketing

Coffee Row

Coffee Row
My Big Brother's Stories

Better Blogger Network

Semper Fidelis

Semper Fidelis
I've been given an award!!!

The Liebster Award

The Liebster Award
My good friend and Amazing Blogger, Marcia of Menopausal Mother awarded me . . .

Irresistibly Sweet Award

Irresistibly Sweet Award
Delores, my good friend from The Feathered Nest, has nominated me!

Sunshine Award!!!

Sunshine Award!!!
My good friend Red from Oz has nominated me!!!

My very own Humorous Blogger Award From Delores at The Feathered Nest!

Be Courageous!


Grab and Add!

Search This Blog

Ghost of the Overlook

Ghost of the Overlook
Need a fright?